Skip to main content

A project coordinated by Cristian Ionita, Ph.D. (University of Montreal) 


MISSION AND OBJECTIVES

Mission

For a HSS research based on integrity and bilingual dialogue

The mission of this initiative is to create an inclusive and credible platform dedicated to academic integrity in the humanities and social sciences in Canada. It aims to provide researchers, students, publishers, and institutions with clear benchmarks, reliable resources, and critical reflections on ethical practices in scholarly publishing. By taking into account both linguistic spheres, French and English, the project promotes dialogue and transparency. It also seeks to anticipate challenges related to artificial intelligence in order to ensure that integrity remains at the heart of research and publishing in HSS.

Objective no. 1

Strengthen transparency and trust in scholarly publishing

The first major objective is to strengthen editorial integrity by proposing transparent frameworks, typologies of misconduct, and practical tools to prevent and manage breaches. The platform will serve as a reference for publishers and institutions, helping them identify risks such as plagiarism, cronyism, or biases in peer review. By disseminating case studies and comparative best practices, it will encourage accountability and fairness in scholarly publishing. This objective emphasizes trust and rigor, which are essential to the credibility of research in HSS.

Objective no. 2

Integrate AI responsibly and ethically into academic practices

The second objective is to critically address the challenges and opportunities related to the introduction of artificial intelligence in scholarly publishing in HSS. The initiative will analyze how AI tools transform writing, revision, and the detection of misconduct, while highlighting the risks of bias, overproduction, or ethical ambiguities. By proposing guidelines and stimulating debate, the platform will help researchers and publishers integrate these technologies in a responsible manner. This objective ensures that technological innovation strengthens, rather than undermines, academic integrity and editorial accountability.


AI and GenAI in brief...

Artificial intelligence (AI) is a technology that enables computers to perform tasks that typically require human intelligence, such as understanding language, recognizing patterns, solving problems, making decisions, and even learning from experience.


Generative AI (GenAI) is a subset of AI whose main characteristic is the ability to create new content, such as text, images, code, audio, and video, based on what it has learned from existing content.

(Definitions proposed by McGill University, Montreal)


Announcing a New Research Project

Generative AI and Scholarly Publishing

(Ithaka S + R, 2024)


General Preamble

This initiative was born from a strong conviction: academic integrity in the humanities and social sciences (HSS) must be defended within a neutral, credible, and open framework. In a Canadian context marked by linguistic and cultural diversity, but also by persistent ideological tensions, it is necessary to create a space where reflection on scientific misconduct can unfold without being hindered by political polarizations.

From its foundation, the project was built around a principle of anonymity designed to protect collaborators against ad hominem attacks and ideological divisions. This anonymity allows attention to shift from persons to ideas, from affiliations to principles, and ensures that debate remains focused on scientific rigor and collective responsibility. However, some founding members have chosen to forgo this principle, believing that responsibility for the message should be publicly embodied. Their decision illustrates a dual dynamic: protecting neutrality through anonymity, while also affirming responsibility through visibility. This articulation reflects the project's maturity and its desire to combine prudence with commitment.

Our mission is to build a bilingual platform that serves as a reference for researchers, students, publishers, and institutions. It rests on two major objectives: strengthening editorial integrity by proposing transparent frameworks, typologies of misconduct, and practical tools; and critically addressing contemporary challenges related to artificial intelligence, which is transforming writing, revision, and dissemination practices. These objectives reflect a desire to preserve the credibility of research while anticipating the technological and social changes affecting scholarly publishing.

Our openness to dialogue is essential. We invite external voices to contribute, share their experiences, and clarify sensitive points. Feedback, whether anonymous or publicly acknowledged, enriches collective reflection and adds weight to the debate. It helps highlight concrete cases related to academic integrity in Canada and contributes to maintaining a sound and healthy spirit in research and publishing.

This initiative aims to be a space of trust and dialogue, where academic integrity is discussed in a principled manner. It combines anonymity and responsibility, neutrality and commitment, to affirm that scientific integrity is a universal value, independent of ideological divisions, but carried by actors who fully embrace the strength of the founding message.



See also

Artificial Intelligence and the Social Sciences and Humanities

(Open Research Europe)